auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Study: Failure to Capture Off Make Buyers Costs Auto Groups Service Revenue

A new study commissioned by Affinitiv finds U.S. auto groups lose up to $230,000 in per-store service revenue by failing to cross-market off make used car buyers.

December 3, 2019
Study: Failure to Capture Off Make Buyers Costs Auto Groups Service Revenue

Affinitiv analysts found the average repair order amount is 68% higher for same make vehicles, no matter the brand.

Photo by Negative Space via Pexels

2 min to read


CHICAGO — When dealers fail to refer used off make buyers to sister stores within their auto group for service, the group loses up to $230,000 annually in potential customer pay revenue per store, according to Affinitiv’s Automotive Customer Loyalty study.

The study analyzed data from deals at more than 1,000 auto dealerships. Analysts found that, regardless of brand, the average repair order amount is 68% higher for a used same make vehicle than the average RO amount for a used off make vehicle.

Read: Calif. Dealers Get Warranty Rate Hike, 10-Year Upgrade Intervals, CCPA Exemption

“If I buy a used Honda at a Toyota dealership, I might take it back to that dealership for an oil change but it’s unlikely I’ll take it back for a brake job or transmission service,” said Scot Eisenfelder, CEO of Affinitiv. “Lost opportunities occur when the Toyota salesperson fails to transfer that customer’s information over to the Honda store within their group, so the Honda store can market to and win that buyer’s service business.”

“If you convert a used off make buyer into a loyal service customer at another store, that customer is more likely to remain loyal to your auto group brand on the next purchase.”

Calculations revealed that auto groups could increase annual potential customer pay revenue by $230,000 per store simply by closing the service opportunity gap between used off make and used same make buyers.

“This figure doesn’t take into account that if you convert a used off make buyer into a loyal service customer at another store, that customer is more likely to remain loyal to your auto group brand on the next purchase,” noted Doug Van Sach, Affinitiv’s vice president of strategy and analytics.

Read: Survey: Dealer Websites Fail Consumers in 3 Key Areas

More Fixed Ops

Fixed Opsby Hannah MitchellFebruary 20, 2026

Auto Recalls Sank Last Year

2025 Sedgwick data indicate that the number of vehicles affected fell to its lowest point in more than a decade.

Read More →
Technician writing on a clipboard in front of a vehicle wheel with ASE Certified logo displayed on the right side.
Fixed Opsby StaffFebruary 18, 2026

ASE Winter Registration Now Open

The deadline to register for the industry standard certification testing is March 31.

Read More →
StoneEagle and Pencilwrench branding displayed with a headshot of CEO Cindy Allen alongside NADA Show 2026 event information.
Fixed Opsby StaffJanuary 29, 2026

Pencilwrench Repair Experience Debuts at NADA

StoneEagle's Flex Story marks an evolution in how Pencilwrench can help technicians document repair work, shaped by growing complexity of vehicle diagnostics.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Technician in a blue coverall holding a wrench in an auto repair shop, with cars in the background.
Fixed Opsby StaffDecember 10, 2025

ASE Fall Registration Deadline Dec. 31

Technicians are encouraged to sign up for certification.

Read More →
Promotional graphic for the “Voice of Technician Survey is now open” with ASE and WrenchWay logos and a “Take the survey” button over a vehicle service bay background.
Fixed Opsby StaffDecember 4, 2025

ASE, WrenchWay Survey Auto Technicians

Voice of Technician poll intended to get input on the challenges and pluses of auto repair and maintenance work.

Read More →
Fixed Opsby Lauren LawrenceNovember 18, 2025

U.S. Drivers Overdue for Major Services

Data shows dealers have ample opportunity ahead of the holiday travel season.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Industryby StaffNovember 11, 2025

Auto Dealers Losing Service Customers

Study finds that though overall service drive revenue is up, loyalty is eroding

Read More →
Fixed Opsby Hannah MitchellNovember 4, 2025

Jeeps Can Catch Fire

Hundreds of thousands recalled, some for second time, to address battery flaw

Read More →
Fixed Opsby Hannah MitchellOctober 24, 2025

Ford Doubles Down on Backup Cameras

Automaker, in the middle of a big recall over the devices, offers 15-year warranty

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Fixed Opsby Hannah MitchellOctober 22, 2025

Fords Recalled Due to Fires

Wide range of models affected by engine flaw

Read More →